St. Paul's roof bids come in far apart
Summary
After 30+ years, the village still hasn't decided what to do with the St. Paul's main building. A new independent report pegs full adaptive reuse at ~$80.3 million, says the building is structurally stable, and lays out financing options — but no decision has been made, and residents would vote on any final plan.
At a glance
- Total mentions
- 9
- Last 30 days
- 2
Discussed at 2 meetings in the last 60 days; most recently Nov 5, 2026.
Impact analysis
Any project could cost $30M–$90M depending on the option, potentially $517–$921 per household per year if bonded.
All residents gain clarity on costs and options; supporters of preservation and a community center get a concrete roadmap.
Taxpayers could face significant debt if a large project moves forward.
Mentions & discussions (9)
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Nov 5, 2026
The society donated another $95,000 toward preserving St. Paul's, bringing total private giving to $220,000 since June — money that offsets what taxpayers would otherwise pay.
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Oct 22, 2026
Two bids opened for the St. Paul's Mansard roof: $5.5 million and $12 million. Officials will research and negotiate, with work likely starting on the east side where the largest hole is.
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Sep 10, 2026
Big progress at St. Paul's: ivy and fire escapes removed, roof bid out with October opening, a new water main going in this month, landscaping by Thanksgiving, and a $125,000 contribution from the Landmark Society toward the effort.
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Jul 16, 2026
The village landed its first big private gift for St. Paul's — $125,000 from the new Landmark Society — plus $10,000 in landscape design services from Westminster Nursery. Work on the building's exterior, windows, and entrance restoration is well underway, with the Mansard roof RFP going out soon.
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Jun 25, 2026
Old fire escapes are coming down, carpentry and entrance refurbishment begin this summer, and an RFP for the mansard roof is nearly ready. Two philanthropy groups are raising money and a landscape firm may donate design services for a botanical-garden-style grounds plan.
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Jun 10, 2026
The new St. Paul's Landmark Society will hand the Village a $125,000 inaugural gift on June 18 to kick off preservation work at the historic school, and plans to fund a full security camera system next. The Village also accepted a separate $50,000 donation of contractor work at St. Paul's.
Board of Trustees (Regular) - May 21, 2026
The village has $10 million set aside to protect and stabilize St. Paul's exterior: a new mansard roof, masonry and structural repairs, security monitoring, donated fire-escape removal and brush clearing. Expect monthly updates and contractor bidding within weeks; roof work starts in the fall. The board insists the $10 million cap will hold and is pursuing grants and philanthropy to offset costs.
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Apr 23, 2026
Trustees added a $10 million placeholder to the new capital budget for St. Paul's exterior preservation — reversing their earlier plan to wait. The money only authorizes planning and cleanup work; any real spending needs a separate bond resolution and board vote. Deputy Mayor Courtney disagreed with the timing; Trustee Catalano supported it, saying it's far cheaper than the $32 million demolition plan and doesn't affect this year's tax rate.
Board of Trustees (Special) - Jan 29, 2026
After 30+ years, the village still hasn't decided what to do with the St. Paul's main building. A new independent report pegs full adaptive reuse at ~$80.3 million, says the building is structurally stable, and lays out financing options — but no decision has been made, and residents would vote on any final plan.
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda and when it's voted on, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for Village of Garden City
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.