St. Paul's demolition cost study and subdivision moratorium
Summary
Mayor Finneran announced the board has withdrawn the public-private partnership option for St. Paul's, and Trustee Muldoon laid out real financing numbers: an $80M adaptive reuse bond would cost a $1.5M homeowner about $680/year, while a ~$40M demolition-and-park over ten years runs about $670/year. Residents pushed back on carrying costs and warned a cathedral-owned park wouldn't replace a village park.
At a glance
- Total mentions
- 2
- Last 30 days
- 0
Last discussed Feb 17, 2026.
Impact analysis
Estimated tax impacts: ~$680/year (adaptive reuse, 30-yr bond) vs ~$670/year (demolition/park, 10-yr note) on a $1.5M home.
Residents who want firm, sourced numbers instead of rumor before the community decides St. Paul's future.
Property owners hoping to subdivide land face continued delay of permits until the new law is ready.
Mentions & discussions (2)
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Feb 17, 2026
Mayor Finneran announced the board has withdrawn the public-private partnership option for St. Paul's, and Trustee Muldoon laid out real financing numbers: an $80M adaptive reuse bond would cost a $1.5M homeowner about $680/year, while a ~$40M demolition-and-park over ten years runs about $670/year. Residents pushed back on carrying costs and warned a cathedral-owned park wouldn't replace a village park.
Board of Trustees (Regular) - Feb 5, 2026
The village will issue an RFP to get professional pricing on demolishing St. Paul's, and the subdivision moratorium will be extended from mid-February into mid-May while new subdivision rules are drafted. Trustees stressed no decision has been made and any major project will require a majority vote of residents.
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda and when it's voted on, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for Village of Garden City
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.